Bungie’s attempt to dismiss the copyright case concerning Destiny 2 based on YouTube videos about ‘vaulted’ elements has been rejected by a judge, who deemed that merely citing long videos was not sufficient.

The essence of the lawsuit stems from allegations that Bungie has used elements from a blog post by sci-fi writer Matthew Kelsey Martineau. The court has expressed the importance of a thorough investigation into the case, maintaining that significant developments shall proceed.

Currently, old material from Destiny 2 is no longer accessible due to ongoing updates to the game’s engine, making it impossible for Bungie to restore certain content for review. The judge’s ruling reinforces the legal proceedings, suggesting a robust examination of the claims against the game developer.

Destiny 2
(Image credit: Bungie)

In light of the court’s determination, many are questioning the sustainability and approach of live-service games that often render parts unplayable as they transition to new content. This sets a critical precedent in the gaming industry, particularly concerning copyright and content ownership.